They bet the wrong first-time starter.

While firster Tossup took a ton of money, going off as the 7-2 second chioce, it was the ignored firster, Maiden Beauty, sent off at 22-1, who took the $100,000 Lynbrook Stakes under Joel Rosario for Gary Contessa.

Maiden Beauty is the third first-time starter to win the Lynbrook.

Tossup, who lugged in some during the stretch run, got second narrowly over Midnitesalright.